The HR Value Chain is a model that demonstrates how benefit obtained from HR Management & processes can contributes value towards an organization achieving its objectives.
In today’s article, we’re going to be investigating this model – the HR value chain, we’ll look at what it is, how it’s used, and some of its associated benefits and weaknesses.
Table of Contents
- What is the HR Value Chain
- HR Value Chain Diagram
- HR Value Chain Analysis
- HR Processes
- HR Effectiveness
- HR Impact
- Methods of proving HR effectiveness
- Alternative HR Value Chain models
- Benefits of HR Value Chain
- Criticisms of the HR Value Chain
What is the HR Value Chain
The HR value chain:
- Is a step by step model
- It commences with HR processes,
- It demonstrates the outcomes associated with HR process (which are often HR objectives)
- It demonstrates how HR outcomes lead to organizational goals.
The result is that the HR Value chain demonstrates two things
- It demonstrates value
- It demonstrates the explicit association between HR functions and the achievement of strategic/company goals.
This can help answer this simple question
“What value does HR add to your company?”
The fundamental fact is that in many organizations, HR struggles to demonstrate value and is often seen as an administerial overhead.
To answer the question correctly a business needs a method by which to articulate the journey in which value is added.
HR Value Chain Diagram
The Value chain can be presented in various ways; the most common are:
Three-stage HR Value Chain
HR Value Chain Chart
HR Value Chain Analysis
Let’s now look at how the HR value chain is constructed.
As you can see from the left hand side of the three stage diagram the first input is the activities the HR functioned undertakes – it’s processes – these will typically include:
- Talent management
- Resource planning
- Benefits Management
(you can see more about HR functions here – https://sanzubusinesstraining.com/human-resources-functions/)
An organization that is process-focused (i.e, generally more interested in cost management (i.e., reducing cost)) is at this maturity within the model.
The next stage in the value chain is the outcomes of the processes – their effectiveness – often what is measured through traditional HR KPI’s.
Being effective means that we are accomplishing a positive outcome.
This section will typically include:
- Staff retention
- Workforce Cost
Measuring effectiveness is often seen as a challenge. If you contrast HR with, say, production, where production can demonstrate value by the number of parts manufactured, HR requires an equivalent method that effectiveness is met.
This is where appropriate metrics come in.
A dichotomy is that the HR function can excel at designing & deploying processes, but if they are not executed effectively by the organization (i.e line managers), performance will be low.
A company that focuses on this stage of the model concentrates on achieving positive outcomes at low cost.
The final step is to associate the impact of the process to the corporate objective
For example Staff Competency may drive Productivity.
This section will typically articulate corporate goals.
These may include:
- Financial measures (i.e, profit)
- Market share
- Customer Satisfaction
An organization that focuses on stage three of the model can be determined as strategic and will focus on the contribution of its HR policies and processes.
Methods of proving HR effectiveness
The value chain indicates that most businesses will fall into one of three groups:
1/ A focus on cost (focusing on the left-hand side of the model)
2/ A focus on HR performance ( a focus on the middle of the model)
3/ A focus on business results (a focus on the right of the model)
A method of improving effectiveness means moving through the value chain.
Alternative HR Value chain models
While this three column value chain is the model typically utilized, there have been several modifications to this which include:
1/ The Harvard HR model
This focuses on varying levels of outcomes and how this can feedback into HR policies and procedures
2/ Four stage model
This presumes that HR processes and performance react to an external/internal force i.e. a problem:
3/Advanced HR Value Chain Model
This demonstrates how the HR function ultimately interfaces with corporate strategy, customers and how it’s performance can be driven by enablers (i.e funding)
Benefits of HR Value Chain
The key benefits of the HR Value Chain include:
- Helps articulate how value is obtained from HR Management
- Able to identify weaknesses in business focus that may impact objectives
- Articulates a maturity journey an organization can undertake
- Simple/easy to understand
- Almost universal application
Criticisms of the HR Value Chain
- The model is too simplistic and lacks ability to deal with nuances.
- Doesn’t articulate best practice (merely describes a journey)
- Does not explain how linkages within the chain can be exploited
- Does not explain the time taken to reach maturity
- In its simple form it does not explain tools (or other enablers) that may be required to drive maturity
- No weighting of activities (i.e., do some processes offer more towards goals/objectives than others).
The HR Value Chain provides an important methodology in order to articulate the value that HR can provide to an organization.
Where are you in your journey in understanding the value your Human Resources function is adding? Do you have any comments on the above article? Perhaps you have some experience in Analytics and how HR KPI’s have been linked to organizations’ objectives.
We’d love to hear your feedback, you can reach us on Twitter or utilize the comments section below.
This article is part of our Human Resources Guide.